Looking to upgrade your trailer? We've got great news for you! At Mayes Trailer Sales, we offer you two fantastic options to make your trailer transition smooth and rewarding. You can sell your current trailer to us, getting a fair and competitive price. Alternatively, if you have your eye on a new model in our inventory, consider trading in your old trailer. Trading in allows you to seamlessly upgrade while enjoying the convenience of a one-stop solution. Whatever your choice, we're here to ensure you have a hassle-free experience. Contact us today to explore your options and make your trailer dreams a reality!
Visit or Call Our Indianapolis Area Dealership
Mayes Trailer Sales has been on U.S. 31 in New Whiteland since the 1990s, about twenty minutes south of downtown Indianapolis. We stock dump trailers, equipment trailers, utility trailers, enclosed cargo trailers, car haulers, gooseneck trailers, tilt trailers, deckover trailers, dump bins and tow dollies.
Have questions about inventory, parts or service? Call or text us at (317) 535-5901, email the department you need directly, or stop by the lot. The team below answers their own email.
| Feature | Traditional Financing | Rent-to-Own (RTO) |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Lower interest rates & long-term ownership | Maximum flexibility & zero credit checks |
| Credit Requirement | All credit scores considered (soft pre-check) | No credit check required |
| Approval Speed | Minutes to 24 hours | Instant approval |
| Ownership Structure | Direct loan purchase | Lease with option to buy |
| Early Payoff | No prepayment penalties | Flexible payoff options |
Application Requirements Checklist
-
Government-Issued ID: Driver’s License or State Photo ID.
-
Proof of Income: Recent pay stub, bank statement, or tax document (for startups/businesses)
-
Proof of Residence: Utility bill or official mail matching your home address.
-
References: 2 to 4 personal or professional contact references.
-
Down Payment: Debit/Credit Card or Cash (amount depends on approved loan terms).
Smart Payment Options for Every Credit Profile
We believe in teamwork and accessibility, which is why we offer financing solutions for all credit scores. If traditional financing isn't the right path for you, explore our hassle-free Rent-to-Own (RTO) programs—featuring instant approvals, flexible terms, and absolutely no credit checks. We also proudly welcome start-ups and new commercial businesses looking to build or expand their fleet without financial stress.
-
Fast & Easy Application: Get a decision in minutes.
-
Flexible Programs: Choose between traditional financing or Rent-to-Own.
-
No Hidden Fees: Transparent terms from Indiana's leading dealership.
Don't put your business or personal projects on hold. Fill out our secure Financing Form below, or visit our convenient lot in New Whiteland, Indiana, to speak with a trailer expert today!
Where is Mayes Trailer Sales located and what are your business hours?
We are located at 1101 N U.S. 31, New Whiteland, IN 46184
-
Monday – Friday: 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
-
Wednesday: 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM (Regular hours) + 5:00 PM – 7:00 PM (By appointment only)
-
Saturdays: 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM
How can I contact a specific department directly?
You can call or text us anytime at (317) 535-5901
-
Sales Team:
sales@mayestrailer.com -
Trailer Service: Mark Shonkwiler (
mshonkwiler@mayestrailer.com) -
Parts Manager: Steve Goins (
sgoins@mayestrailer.com)
Do you offer financing options for trailer purchases?
Yes! We provide financing solutions designed to accommodate all credit scores
How does the Rent-to-Own (RTO) program work?
Our Rent-to-Own program is a hassle-free alternative to traditional financing
-
Instant approvals
-
No credit checks
-
Flexible terms with no hidden fees
What trailer types and brands do you carry?
We carry an extensive inventory including heavy-duty dump trailers, flatbeds, enclosed cargo trailers, utility trailers, and equipment haulers